Get the free Reviewer Comments to Author(s):

Name: Fillable Online Reviewer Comments to Author(s): Fax Email Print - pdfFiller
Brand: pdfFiller
Rating: 4.2 (50 reviews)

Get Form

Show details

Reviewer Comments to Author(s): Reviewer #1 (Dillon Wander Was, PhD): Overall, this is a clear, concise, and well written manuscript. The introduction is relevant and theory based. Sufficient information

We are not affiliated with any brand or entity on this form

Get, Create, Make and Sign reviewer comments to authors

Edit your reviewer comments to authors form online

Type text, complete fillable fields, insert images, highlight or blackout data for discretion, add comments, and more.

Add your legally-binding signature

Draw or type your signature, upload a signature image, or capture it with your digital camera.

Share your form instantly

Email, fax, or share your reviewer comments to authors form via URL. You can also download, print, or export forms to your preferred cloud storage service.

How to edit reviewer comments to authors online

Ease of Setup

pdfFiller User Ratings on G2

Ease of Use

pdfFiller User Ratings on G2

To use our professional PDF editor, follow these steps:

1

Set up an account. If you are a new user, click Start Free Trial and establish a profile.

2

Prepare a file. Use the Add New button to start a new project. Then, using your device, upload your file to the system by importing it from internal mail, the cloud, or adding its URL.

3

Edit reviewer comments to authors. Add and change text, add new objects, move pages, add watermarks and page numbers, and more. Then click Done when you're done editing and go to the Documents tab to merge or split the file. If you want to lock or unlock the file, click the lock or unlock button.

4

Get your file. When you find your file in the docs list, click on its name and choose how you want to save it. To get the PDF, you can save it, send an email with it, or move it to the cloud.

pdfFiller makes working with documents easier than you could ever imagine. Register for an account and see for yourself!

Uncompromising security for your PDF editing and eSignature needs

Your private information is safe with pdfFiller. We employ end-to-end encryption, secure cloud storage, and advanced access control to protect your documents and maintain regulatory compliance.

Learn more about security & compliance

How to fill out reviewer comments to authors

How to fill out reviewer comments to authors:

01

Begin by introducing yourself and your role as a reviewer. Provide a brief overview of the manuscript you have reviewed.

02

Clearly state your main points of feedback. This can include areas where the manuscript could be improved, concerns about methodology or data analysis, or suggestions for further research or discussion.

03

Be specific in your comments and provide evidence or examples to support your feedback. This helps the authors understand your perspective and provides them with actionable suggestions.

04

Organize your comments in a logical and concise manner. Consider using headings or bullet points to make your feedback easier to navigate and understand.

05

Use a constructive tone and avoid being overly critical or negative. Remember that the goal of reviewer comments is to help the authors improve their work, not to discourage them.

06

Finally, conclude your comments by summarizing your main points and offering a positive note or encouragement to the authors.

Who needs reviewer comments to authors?

Reviewers, typically experts in the field, provide feedback to authors in order to ensure the quality and rigor of the research being conducted. These comments are important for authors as they help them identify areas for improvement, address any concerns raised by the reviewers, and enhance the overall quality of their work. Additionally, reviewer comments are essential for the peer review process, which is crucial for maintaining the integrity and credibility of academic and scientific publications. Thus, both reviewers and authors rely on the reviewer comments for the advancement of knowledge and the improvement of research outcomes.

Fill form : Try Risk Free

Rate the form

4.2

Satisfied

50 Votes

For pdfFiller’s FAQs

Below is a list of the most common customer questions. If you can’t find an answer to your question, please don’t hesitate to reach out to us.

How can I send reviewer comments to authors to be eSigned by others?

To distribute your reviewer comments to authors, simply send it to others and receive the eSigned document back instantly. Post or email a PDF that you've notarized online. Doing so requires never leaving your account.

How do I complete reviewer comments to authors online?

Easy online reviewer comments to authors completion using pdfFiller. Also, it allows you to legally eSign your form and change original PDF material. Create a free account and manage documents online.

How do I fill out reviewer comments to authors using my mobile device?

You can easily create and fill out legal forms with the help of the pdfFiller mobile app. Complete and sign reviewer comments to authors and other documents on your mobile device using the application. Visit pdfFiller’s webpage to learn more about the functionalities of the PDF editor.

What is reviewer comments to authors?

Reviewer comments to authors are feedback provided by peer reviewers to the authors of a manuscript regarding the quality and content of their work.

Who is required to file reviewer comments to authors?

Peer reviewers are required to file reviewer comments to authors after reviewing a manuscript.

How to fill out reviewer comments to authors?

Reviewers can fill out reviewer comments to authors by providing constructive feedback, highlighting strengths and weaknesses, and suggesting improvements.

What is the purpose of reviewer comments to authors?

The purpose of reviewer comments to authors is to help authors improve their manuscript, guide editorial decisions, and maintain the quality of scholarly publications.

What information must be reported on reviewer comments to authors?

Reviewer comments to authors must include specific feedback on the methodology, results, discussion, and conclusions of the manuscript.

Fill out your reviewer comments to authors online with pdfFiller!

pdfFiller is an end-to-end solution for managing, creating, and editing documents and forms in the cloud. Save time and hassle by preparing your tax forms online.

Get started now