Get the free Manuscript Evaluation Form

This form is intended for reviewers to evaluate manuscripts submitted to the Journal of International Business Ethics, ensuring a blind review process while providing constructive feedback.

How to fill out manuscript evaluation form

How to fill out Manuscript Evaluation Form

1. Begin by entering the title of the manuscript at the top of the form.
2. Fill in the author's name and any co-authors' names in the designated section.
3. Provide your contact information as the evaluator, including your name, email, and affiliation.
4. Read the manuscript thoroughly to gain a clear understanding of its content and purpose.
5. Evaluate the manuscript based on the provided criteria, such as originality, significance, and clarity of writing.
6. For each criterion, provide specific comments and ratings as required by the form.
7. Include any suggestions for improvement or additional remarks in the designated section.
8. Review your evaluation to ensure clarity and completeness before submitting the form.

Who needs Manuscript Evaluation Form?

1. Researchers submitting manuscripts to academic journals.
2. Editors who need to assess the quality and suitability of submissions.
3. Peer reviewers tasked with providing feedback on manuscripts.
4. Publishers seeking to evaluate the potential of new publications.

People Also Ask about

What is a manuscript evaluation?

A manuscript evaluation is an in-depth, developmental, and structural manuscript editing report. It provides a bigger picture of the manuscript by deeply analyzing of its many facts.

What is the difference between developmental editing and substantive editing?

Substantive editing considers a work's organization and presentation. It involves tightening and clarifying at a chapter, scene, paragraph, and sentence level. Unlike developmental editing, which covers the big-picture issues and deep-level restructuring, substantive editing deals with the actual prose.

Who evaluate the quality of manuscripts submitted for publication?

Peer review, in which peer experts evaluate the value of a manuscript submitted to a professional journal, is regarded as a crucial step in publication.

How much does a manuscript evaluation cost?

The cost of a manuscript assessment can range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars, depending on factors like manuscript length, genre, and the assessor's experience. A basic assessment might start around $500, while a comprehensive evaluation could exceed $2,000.

What is the meaning of developmental editing?

Developmental editing is a form of writing support that comes into play before or during the production of a publishable manuscript, in fiction, non-fiction, and academic writing (including textbooks).

What is the difference between manuscript evaluation and developmental editing?

If a developmental edit involves asking the author multiple questions, a manuscript evaluation gives you a high-level overview of what works and what doesn't. In an evaluation, I might refer to books, blogs and other resources that explain a given concept in depth.

How to do a manuscript evaluation?

After your first reading, write one or two paragraphs summarizing what the manuscript is about and how it adds to current knowledge in your field. Mention the strengths of the manuscript, but also any problems that make you believe it should not be published, or that would need to be corrected to make it publishable.

What is the difference between an editorial assessment and a developmental edit?

I like to think of it in these terms: the editorial assessment provides you with a road map. The developmental edit gives you the map as well as turn-by-turn directions. I define an editorial assessment as a comprehensive review of a book's strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities for revision.

For pdfFiller’s FAQs

What is Manuscript Evaluation Form?

The Manuscript Evaluation Form is a document used by publishers or editors to assess the quality, relevance, and suitability of a submitted manuscript for publication.

Who is required to file Manuscript Evaluation Form?

Typically, authors submitting a manuscript are required to fill out the Manuscript Evaluation Form, which may also involve reviewers providing their evaluations.

How to fill out Manuscript Evaluation Form?

To fill out the Manuscript Evaluation Form, the evaluator should read the manuscript thoroughly, provide feedback on specific criteria (such as originality, methodology, clarity, etc.), and complete all sections of the form as instructed.

What is the purpose of Manuscript Evaluation Form?

The purpose of the Manuscript Evaluation Form is to provide a structured way for reviewers and editors to give feedback on a manuscript, ensuring consistency and thoroughness in the evaluation process.

What information must be reported on Manuscript Evaluation Form?

The form typically requires information such as the manuscript title, author(s), evaluation ratings on various criteria, constructive comments, and recommendations regarding publication potential.