Get the free Proposing a manuscript peer-review checklist - hal inserm

Proposing a manuscript peer review checklist. Simon Duchess, Pierre Jacinto cite this version: Simon Duchess, Pierre Tannin. Proposing a manuscript peer review checklist. Neuroimaging, Elsevier, 2008,

How to fill out proposing a manuscript peer-review

How to fill out proposing a manuscript peer-review:

1. Start by thoroughly reading the manuscript and understanding its main findings and arguments.
2. Take note of any discrepancies, inconsistencies, or areas that need clarification within the manuscript.
3. Analyze the methodology and experimental design to ensure they are sound and reliable.
4. Evaluate the organization and structure of the manuscript, checking if it flows logically and if the sections are properly labeled.
5. Assess the language and writing style for clarity and coherence, suggesting improvements if necessary.
6. Pay attention to the references cited and cross-check them for accuracy and relevance.
7. Make constructive comments on the strengths and weaknesses of the manuscript, providing suggestions for improvement.
8. Consider the ethical aspects of the research, such as the treatment of human subjects or the use of animals.
9. After reviewing the main content, provide an overall recommendation to accept, reject, or revise the manuscript.
10. Summarize your review in a clear and concise manner, addressing each point you have raised during the evaluation process.

Who needs proposing a manuscript peer-review:

1. Authors: Authors often need to propose their manuscript for peer-review in order to have it evaluated by experts in the field. This helps ensure the quality and validity of their findings before publication.
2. Editors: Editors of scientific journals rely on the peer-review process to determine if a manuscript meets the journal's standards for publication. They rely on the expertise of reviewers to make informed decisions.
3. Reviewers: Reviewers are an essential component of the peer-review process. They need to propose a manuscript for review in order to provide an unbiased evaluation of the research, helping authors improve their work and demonstrating the integrity of the scientific community.
4. Research institutions and universities: In academic settings, proposing a manuscript for peer-review is crucial to maintain scientific rigor and credibility. Researchers and scholars are encouraged to have their work reviewed to ensure its quality and contribute to the advancement of knowledge in their respective fields.

For pdfFiller’s FAQs

What is proposing a manuscript peer-review?

Proposing a manuscript peer-review involves suggesting potential reviewers for a manuscript to evaluate its quality and provide feedback before publication.

Who is required to file proposing a manuscript peer-review?

Authors or researchers submitting a manuscript for publication are typically required to propose peer-reviewers.

How to fill out proposing a manuscript peer-review?

To fill out a proposing a manuscript peer-review, authors must provide the names and contact information of recommended reviewers along with a justification for their selection.

What is the purpose of proposing a manuscript peer-review?

The purpose of proposing a manuscript peer-review is to ensure that the manuscript undergoes a thorough evaluation by experts in the field to improve its quality and validity.

What information must be reported on proposing a manuscript peer-review?

Authors must report the names, affiliations, and contact details of proposed reviewers, along with a brief explanation of why each reviewer is suitable to evaluate the manuscript.

How can I modify proposing a manuscript peer-review without leaving Google Drive?

You can quickly improve your document management and form preparation by integrating pdfFiller with Google Docs so that you can create, edit and sign documents directly from your Google Drive. The add-on enables you to transform your proposing a manuscript peer-review into a dynamic fillable form that you can manage and eSign from any internet-connected device.

How can I send proposing a manuscript peer-review for eSignature?

proposing a manuscript peer-review is ready when you're ready to send it out. With pdfFiller, you can send it out securely and get signatures in just a few clicks. PDFs can be sent to you by email, text message, fax, USPS mail, or notarized on your account. You can do this right from your account. Become a member right now and try it out for yourself!

Can I edit proposing a manuscript peer-review on an Android device?

You can edit, sign, and distribute proposing a manuscript peer-review on your mobile device from anywhere using the pdfFiller mobile app for Android; all you need is an internet connection. Download the app and begin streamlining your document workflow from anywhere.